Opens in a new tab
Home/Blog/ChatGPT Ads vs. Google Search Ads: What Early Data Means for Movers
PPC

ChatGPT Ads vs. Google Search Ads: What Early Data Means for Movers

November 16, 2026·By Brad Leiphart, CEO of NetConnect Digital
ChatGPT Ads vs. Google Search Ads: What Early Data Means for Movers

Search Engine Journal just published a timely review of early ChatGPT Ads compared with Google Search Ads. In ChatGPT Ads Vs. Google Search Ads: What Early Data Shows, Matt G. Southern examines a working paper, a university press statement, and three agency case studies. For a moving or storage company, the question is practical: should some of your Google Ads budget move to ChatGPT Ads?

Our take is conservative. Test ChatGPT Ads with a small, separately tracked budget. Keep Google Search as the lead engine for now. Compare ChatGPT Ads vs Google Search Ads on cost per booked job or qualified lead, with matching attribution windows, not on cost per click. Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) — being cited organically in ChatGPT answers — is the path that does not require ad spend.

Every figure below comes from Southern’s article, or from the study and agencies it names. None are NetConnect Digital campaign results, and this post does not claim we have run ChatGPT Ads for clients.

What early data shows about revenue and conversions

Abstract analytics dashboard with two side-by-side blank charts and metric cards, suggesting a revenue-per-session comparison

In U.S. traffic, Search Engine Journal reports that paid search generated $2.45 in revenue per session, versus $0.89 from ChatGPT ad sessions. Transactions per session were 1.17% against 0.37%. Those pooled figures come from a working paper by Kaiser and Schulze, covering 102 websites over 60 weeks through August 22, with up to 28 weeks of ChatGPT ad sessions in U.S. traffic.

Out of 87 advertisers who used both channels in U.S. traffic, 84 produced less revenue per session using ChatGPT ads. The authors call the comparison descriptive rather than causal. They do not argue that shifting dollars from search to ChatGPT under matched campaigns would help or hurt a specific advertiser.

About 20% of the sites were services, software, education, or finance businesses, which report conversions as bookings, leads, licenses, or sign-ups. Southern notes that the paper still calls a transaction a completed order. For movers, a quote request is not a booked job.

Southern contacted OpenAI about the study. A spokesperson said it “captures an earlier period of ChatGPT Ads’ development and extrapolates platform performance from a small sample,” and that OpenAI has kept launching products, including Target CPA and Target CPC.

Why the per-dollar comparison depends on click prices

Two monitors on a dark desk: a generic chat-style ad dashboard with blank message bubbles and a line chart, beside a generic search-ads dashboard with blank campaign rows and bar charts

A Frankfurt School press statement, covered in the same article, cites an estimate that advertisers receive $0.52 back in revenue for every dollar spent on ChatGPT Ads, compared with $3.40 for every dollar spent on Google Search.

Only the per-session revenue metric was actually measured. Southern notes that the $0.52 and $3.40 figures combine that measured performance with the average cost-per-click from one ChatGPT account and the median from 16 paid search accounts, so the estimate varies with what an advertiser pays per click.

Those click prices were $1.72 for ChatGPT, from one Opascope account, and a $0.72 median for search. The search price was not matched to the revenue each site generated. If your Google or ChatGPT clicks differ from those prices, the math will change. Do not treat $0.52 versus $3.40 as a universal return on ad spend.

What agency case studies actually measured

Agency desk at night with blank report folders and a laptop showing abstract unlabeled charts

Search Engine Journal also summarizes three agency reports. Each covers one advertiser or one test, and all three come down to what happened after the click.

StubGroup ran Google and ChatGPT Ads campaigns for a B2B compliance company for 30 days. ChatGPT clicks cost $0.76, and Google Search clicks cost $10.46. Cost per lead was $92.21 on ChatGPT and $157.57 on Google. The agency said Google leads appeared to convert to customers at a greater rate so far, so cost per customer appeared lower for Google, but the client’s long sales cycle was still open. It also said the $0.76 cost per click was low compared with some of its other clients.

Workshop Digital spent its own funds on ChatGPT Ads and received zero qualified leads from ChatGPT ads and two qualified leads from Google. The agency called the campaigns “not a direct comparison” and did not provide the Google Search spend or dates.

Brafton ran one click campaign from June 17 to August 28. Zach Shah, Brafton’s director of paid media, said ChatGPT ads are “priced like search, but seem to behave like paid social.”

Cheaper clicks, and even a lower cost per lead, can still produce a higher cost per customer if the leads are weaker or slower to close.

What this means for moving and storage companies

Tablet showing an abstract two-channel comparison in front of moving boxes and a blank moving truck

Most of the paper’s revenue-per-session numbers come from sites that can complete an order on the visit. A moving company usually cannot. The customer requests a quote, a coordinator qualifies the job, and a booked move may close days or weeks later.

That is why cost per click is the wrong decision metric, even when ChatGPT clicks look inexpensive next to competitive moving keywords on Google Search. A cheaper click that becomes an unqualified form fill can cost more than an expensive click that becomes a booked move. Compare the channels on cost per qualified lead and, when the sales cycle allows, cost per booked job.

Define a qualified lead the same way on both channels, and give those leads the same amount of time to convert. If one channel gets credit for seven days and the other for 30, the test will mislead you. For movers, Search remains the engine that captures high-intent queries when a household is ready to hire. Our PPC management work is still built around that intent.

How to test ChatGPT Ads without cutting Google Search

Two separate budget trays on a desk, one glowing orange and one navy, suggesting a small separately tracked test budget

Fund the test as a small, separately tracked budget. Do not pull spend from Google Search campaigns that already produce booked jobs until you have enough qualified leads, and enough time after those leads, to compare cost per booked job fairly.

Use the same attribution settings on both channels for the same period. Southern points out that OpenAI’s Ads Manager may include view-through conversions, and that advertisers choose a 7-day, 14-day, or 30-day click window, with a view-through window that can be set to one day or disabled. Both use last-touch logic. Document those settings before you present results against Google Ads or the paper’s figures.

Note the bid strategy you used. Southern reports that since November 9, new conversion campaigns that want a cost target use Target CPA, and new click campaigns can use Target CPC. Max Bid and Max CPC will retire for existing campaigns on January 1, 2027. Those options did not exist during the paper’s data window. Report click or session volume beside the results: a single zero does not distinguish a weak channel from a small test.

AEO is the no-ad-spend route in ChatGPT

Network connecting a central business node to chat, document, website, and map shapes, illustrating organic citations in AI answers

Paid placements are not the only way to show up when someone asks ChatGPT for a mover. Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) is the work of making your business easy for AI-powered tools to understand, trust, and cite. That path does not require a ChatGPT Ads budget.

AEO still depends on crawlable, accurate service pages, consistent business details, and a reputation other sources can confirm. Claiming a ChatGPT business profile is one official channel for those facts; it does not replace ads or being cited in answers. Our guide to ChatGPT business profiles for movers walks through how to claim a listing, and our AEO services cover the broader work. For moving companies, that sits next to the rest of a moving company marketing program, including the Google Search campaigns you should keep running while you test.

FAQ: ChatGPT Ads vs. Google Search Ads for movers

Should moving companies move Google Ads budget to ChatGPT Ads?

Not as a first step. Test ChatGPT Ads with a small, separately tracked budget, keep Google Search as the lead engine, and decide later based on cost per booked job or qualified lead.

Why shouldn’t we compare the two channels on cost per click?

A cheaper click is not a cheaper booked move. Search Engine Journal notes that the $0.52 versus $3.40 per-dollar estimate depends on the click prices used in that calculation.

How should a moving company measure a ChatGPT Ads test?

Use the same definition of a qualified lead on both channels, give those leads the same time to become booked jobs, and use matching attribution windows for the same period.

Do ChatGPT Ads replace Answer Engine Optimization (AEO)?

No. ChatGPT Ads are paid placements. AEO is the work of being cited organically when ChatGPT and other AI tools answer a customer’s question, and it does not require ad spend.

Can NetConnect Digital help us test ChatGPT Ads?

Yes. We can help you keep Google Search as the lead engine, design a small separately tracked test, and compare both channels on cost per qualified lead and booked job. That is planning and measurement work, not a claim that we have already run ChatGPT Ads for clients.

Get a clear read before you move budget

Early ChatGPT Ads data is useful, and it is still early. Search Engine Journal’s review shows lower revenue per session than paid search in the study’s U.S. traffic, a per-dollar estimate that depends on click prices, and mixed agency results that often come down to lead quality after the click. OpenAI says the study covers an earlier period of the product.

NetConnect Digital has delivered 3,500+ projects since 2008. If you want a second set of eyes on a ChatGPT Ads test plan, or on the Google Search account you should keep running, get a free consultation and choose PPC / Google Ads Management on the form.

Brad Leiphart

About the author

Brad Leiphart

CEO of NetConnect Digital

Brad Leiphart is the CEO of NetConnect Digital, a digital marketing agency in Reading, PA. Since 2008, NetConnect Digital has completed 3,500+ projects for moving and self-storage companies, for agencies through white-label partnerships, and for local businesses. Brad leads the agency's SEO, AEO (Answer Engine Optimization), PPC, and web design work, helping clients grow visibility in search results and AI answers.

Keep Reading

More insight from the NetConnect Digital team on SEO, paid media, web development and growth.

View All Articles
Let's Work Together

Partner With Us

We are strategists, marketers, researchers, and developers who craft custom digital experiences for startups, eCommerce companies, energy, moving and financial services, nonprofit institutions, and brands.

Let's Connect